Avery has a knack of attracting hot guys, but is too dense to notice. His roommate and best friend, Lou, tries to set him up with the hot guy he's partnered with for a project, but it doesn't go as planned. Then there's Avery's nerdy math tutor, Icky (as Lou likes to call him), who ruined everything. Avery hopelessly crushes on him, and it kills Lou because Icky is straight and looks like a nerd from the 90s. At least, that's what Avery let him believe. It was his fault for assuming things. Then there's Gwen and Sammy. Two lesbians who are hopelessly in love with each other but refuse to do anything about it until one of them had enough.